Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Table of Contents

Peanut butter is more than a filling for your kids’ sandwiches, it’s unctuous, creamy and beautifully nutty, and that makes it a fantastic pie filling.

Today’s recipe is not only gluten-free; by substituting sugar with your favorite zero-carb sweetener, you end up with a protein bomb that can keep you nourished and immensely satisfied.

There’s a wide variety of gluten-free bread flours in the market, and although they’re a bit expensive, they’re well worth it. There’s an alternative, though, and you can see it below. Making your own gluten-free flour. You need a few less than ordinary ingredients, but if you make a large batch, you can use it the whole year for all your gluten-free projects.

gluten free peanut butter pie recipe 2 XS

Since this pie’s filling is mostly peanut butter and cream cheese, I thought the pie crust should be chocolatey, and I loved the results. Throw in a tablespoon of cocoa powder to your mix. The pie looks prettier as well!

I have made this pie several times for different groups of friends and family, and there’s some controversy. For some, the filling is too sweet, and for others, it’s just right. That means that you should add the confectioners’ sugar slowly and taste your filling until it is sweet enough for you. There’s no one correct answer; we all like our food differently.

No matter how much sugar you add, you’ll love this peanut butter pie; it’s so original! And it’s festive enough to be your go-to birthday cake. That’s what I did, and it has worked just fine.

How to Make It

Discover More Recipes

  • Prep Time30 min
  • Cook Time15 min
  • Total Time45 min
  • Serving Size6
  • Energy922 cal


For the gluten-free flour (2.5 cups):

For the pie crust:

For the filling:



In a food processor, add the gluten-free flour, salt, butter and sugar. Pulse until combined but crumbly.


Slowly pour the water while pulsing to create a dough.


Preheat the oven to 400°F.


Flour a surface with gluten-free flour, roll the dough thinly and extend it.


Line a pie mold with the dough.


Bake the crust in the pie mold for 10-15 minutes until golden and crispy. Remove and let it cool down.


In a new mixing bowl, mix the peanut butter, cream cheese and sugar until smooth.


Pour the peanut butter filling over the pie crust, smoothen it out with a knife.


Refrigerate for 2 hours before serving.

  • Nutrition Facts

  • Serving Size6
  • Amount per serving
  • Calories922
  • % Daily Value*Standard DV
  • Total Fat65.8 g78 g84.36%
  • Saturated Fat32.4 g20 g162%
  • Cholesterol123 mg300 mg41%
  • Sodium758 mg2300 mg32.96%
  • Total Carbohydrate74.1 g275 g26.95%
  • Dietary Fiber4.8 g28 g17.14%
  • Total Sugars6.7 g
  • Protein16.1 g50 g32.2%
  • Calcium46 mg1300 mg3.54%
  • Iron5 mg18 mg27.78%
  • Potassium344 mg4700 mg7.32%

Share This Recipe

Skip to content